Saddle up for a magical ride with the A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery series, where small-town charm meets supernatural thrills! Written by Lily Harper Hart, this cozy paranormal mystery series follows Hannah Hickok, a young woman who inherits a quirky western-themed performance town in Kentucky called Casper Creek. Just when she thinks she’s starting fresh, Hannah discovers she’s a witch with powers she never knew she had. Blending magic, murder, and a touch of romance, this series is a delightful escape for fans of cozy mysteries and paranormal adventures.
With its unique setting and colorful cast, A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery offers a fresh spin on the witchy genre. From battling demons to solving murders, Hannah’s journey is packed with heart and humor, making it a must-read for those who love a good mystery with a magical twist.
How A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery Began
Lily Harper Hart, a prolific author known for her cozy mystery series, launched A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery in 2019 with The Dirty Coven. Hart, who also writes under the pseudonym Amanda M. Lee, drew inspiration from her love of quirky characters and supernatural settings. The idea of a cosplay western town as a magical nexus gave her the perfect backdrop to explore Hannah’s growth as a witch. Hart’s knack for blending snarky dialogue and heartfelt moments shines through, creating a series that’s both thrilling and comforting.
The Heart of A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery
The series kicks off with The Dirty Coven (2019), where Hannah arrives in Casper Creek after inheriting the town from her grandmother. A murder rocks her first day, and she learns she’s descended from a line of witches. In A Fistful of Demons (2019), Hannah faces a demon invasion, testing her fledgling powers alongside security chief Cooper Wyatt. Boot Scootin’ Boogeyman (2020) dives into missing women and a creepy boogeyman, while Poltergeist Rider (2023) tackles ghostly chaos. Each book weaves a standalone mystery with ongoing character arcs.
Themes of self-discovery, community, and resilience run deep. Casper Creek’s old-west vibe, complete with staged bank robberies and mai tai-serving saloons, adds a playful charm. Hart’s cozy style mixes paranormal elements—witches, demons, and ghosts—with romantic tension between Hannah and Cooper. The series’ small-town setting feels alive, with quirky locals and supernatural surprises around every corner, making it a standout in the cozy mystery genre.
Why A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery Resonates
A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery has carved a niche among cozy mystery fans for its blend of paranormal fun and heartfelt storytelling. Readers praise Hart’s witty dialogue and immersive world-building, with Goodreads reviews averaging 4.5 stars across the series. The series’ crossovers with Hart’s other works, like Ivy Morgan and Maddie Graves, delight fans, expanding its appeal. Its escapist charm and focus on a strong female lead discovering her power keep readers coming back for more.
With 15 books and counting, the series continues to grow, offering a magical haven for those who crave mystery and enchantment. Its unique western-magical fusion sets it apart, proving that even a lesser-known series can cast a spell on its audience.
- Publication Years: 2019–present
- Number of Books: 15
- Author: Lily Harper Hart
- Genre: Cozy Paranormal Mystery
Ready to trade city life for a witchy western adventure? Grab The Dirty Coven and step into the magical world of A Hannah Hickok Witchy Mystery today!