How to Read An Amish Journey in Order
Written by bestselling Christian fiction author Beth Wiseman, An Amish Journey is a three-book contemporary romance series set within a close-knit Indiana Amish community. The reading order for this series is straightforward, as the chronological timeline matches the order of publication. While each novel functions as a standalone romance, they share recurring family connections and community settings, making it best to read them in the order they were released.
1. Hearts in Harmony (2019)
The series begins with Hearts in Harmony, which introduces Levi Shetler and Mary Hershberger. Both characters share a deep, forbidden passion for music—specifically playing musical instruments, which is prohibited by their strict Amish district. As they secretively share their talents, their mutual love of music blossoms into romance, forcing them to choose between their community's expectations and their personal dreams.
2. Listening to Love (2019)
The second installment, Listening to Love, shifts focus to Levi’s older brother, Lucas Shetler. He forms an unexpected connection with Natalie Collins, an "Englischer" (non-Amish) woman who is struggling with her own personal challenges. Their relationship highlights the cultural clash between the Amish and English worlds, testing Lucas's commitment to his faith and Natalie's willingness to seek healing.
3. A Beautiful Arrangement (2020)
The trilogy concludes with A Beautiful Arrangement. This story centers on Lydia and Samuel Bontrager, who enter a marriage of convenience following an unexpected pregnancy. As they attempt to build a life together based on duty rather than love, they must navigate past wounds, community pressure, and the slow journey toward genuine affection and mutual respect.
Reading Guidance and Connections
If you are looking to dive into the series, here are a few key details to keep in mind:
- Starting Point: Always start with Hearts in Harmony to fully appreciate the Shetler family dynamics before moving to Lucas's story in the second book.
- Chronology: There are no prequels or timeline jumps; the narrative flows directly from book to book.
- Spin-offs & Crossovers: While Beth Wiseman has written other popular series set in Indiana Amish country (such as Daughters of the Promise and the Land of Canaan series), An Amish Journey is a distinct, self-contained trilogy with no direct character crossovers.