Books On Board
series Reading Order

Comfort Food Mystery Books in Order

5 Books
2013 – 2016 Published
Jump to reading order
Affiliate links: We may earn a commission on purchases made at no extra cost to you.
Reading order

The Recommended Reading Order

Since the Comfort Food Mystery series follows a consistent timeline of events, personal relationships, and developments at the Silver Bullet Diner, the best way to read them is in publication order. This order matches the chronological progression of the stories, making it easy to see Trixie Matkowski's journey unfold from the very beginning.

  1. Do or Diner (2013)
  2. A Second Helping of Murder (2014)
  3. Diners, Drive-Ins, and Death (2015)
  4. Macaroni and Freeze (2015)
  5. It's a Wonderful Knife (2016)

Why You Should Read in Order

Reading this series chronologically is highly recommended because of the character-driven subplots. Trixie begins the series after a painful divorce, navigating the challenges of taking over her aunt's diner in the lakeside town of Sandy Harbor, New York. Over the course of the five books, her romantic tension with Deputy Ty Brisco grows, her friendships—particularly with the colorful Antoinette Chloe Brown (ACB)—deepen, and the diner itself evolves. Reading the books out of order will spoil these relationship milestones and diner updates.

Setting and Recipes

The series is set in the fictional town of Sandy Harbor along Lake Ontario. The heart of the town is the Silver Bullet Diner, a 1950s-inspired gem complete with chrome counters and nostalgic charm. To make the reading experience even more immersive, Christine Wenger includes real, mouth-watering comfort food recipes in the back of each book, allowing you to recreate the diner's signature dishes at home.

Spin-offs, Co-authored Books, and Crossovers

There are no spin-offs, crossovers, or co-authored releases in the Comfort Food Mystery universe. While Christine Wenger is also known for her romance novels—including the Gold Buckle Cowboys series—those books remain completely separate from Sandy Harbor and the Silver Bullet Diner.

Frequently Asked

QWhere should I start reading the Comfort Food Mystery series?

You should start with the first book, Do or Diner (2013). This introduces Trixie Matkowski, her move to Sandy Harbor, and how she takes over the Silver Bullet Diner.

QIs the chronological order different from the publication order?

No. The publication order matches the chronological storyline perfectly, tracking Trixie's sleuthing adventures and personal relationships step-by-step.

QAre there recipes included in the Comfort Food Mystery books?

Yes! Each novel in the series features real, diner-style comfort food recipes at the back, so readers can whip up the same dishes Trixie prepares in the stories.

QAre there any spin-off series or companion novellas?

No. The Comfort Food Mystery series consists solely of the five core novels set in Sandy Harbor, with no additional spin-offs, novellas, or crossovers.

QWho published the Comfort Food Mystery books?

The series was published by Penguin Random House under its NAL (New American Library) / Obsidian imprint.

QIs Sandy Harbor, New York, a real town?

No, Sandy Harbor is a fictional, 1950s-inspired lakeside town on Lake Ontario created by Christine Wenger, though it is inspired by her real-life travels through upstate New York.