Books On Board

Pennsylvania Dutch Mysteries Books in Order

  • 24 Books
  • 1993 – 2016 Published

Amazon links here are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reading order
1 of 1 reading orders shown

The Recommended Reading Order

If you want to experience the cozy charms and lighthearted chaos of Hernia, Pennsylvania, the best path forward is simple: read the books in their publication order. The Pennsylvania Dutch Mysteries follow a linear timeline. Because the relationships, the status of the PennDutch Inn, and protagonist Magdalena Yoder's personal life evolve significantly across the books, reading them chronologically prevents major spoilers regarding her marriage, divorce, and recurring local characters.

Here is the complete chronological list of the Pennsylvania Dutch Mysteries in order of release:

  1. Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth (1993)
  2. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Crime (1995)
  3. No Use Dying Over Spilled Milk (1996)
  4. Just Plain Pickled to Death (1997)
  5. Between a Wok and a Hard Place (1998)
  6. Eat, Drink and Be Wary (1998)
  7. Play It Again, Spam (1999)
  8. The Hand That Rocks the Ladle (2000)
  9. The Crepes of Wrath (2001)
  10. Gruel and Unusual Punishment (2002)
  11. Custard's Last Stand (2003)
  12. Thou Shalt Not Grill (2004)
  13. Assault and Pepper (2005)
  14. Grape Expectations (2006)
  15. Hell Hath No Curry (2007)
  16. As the World Churns (2008)
  17. Batter Off Dead (2009)
  18. Butter Safe Than Sorry (2010)
  19. The Death of Pie (2014)
  20. Tea with Jam and Dread (2016)
  21. Puddin' on the Blitz (2019)
  22. Mean and Shellfish (2021)
  23. Death by Tart Attack (2022)
  24. Meat Thy Maker (2023)

What to Know Before You Start

The series is set in the fictional town of Hernia, Pennsylvania, and revolves around the PennDutch Inn, a local establishment run by the sharp-tongued Mennonite innkeeper Magdalena Yoder. Drawing heavily on author Tamar Myers' own Mennonite heritage and childhood roots, the books balance lighthearted mystery with authentic insights into both Amish and Mennonite cultures.

A signature feature of the series is its integration of culinary themes. Almost every title is a food-related pun, and Myers includes real, traditional Pennsylvania Dutch recipes at the back of each book, ranging from sauerkraut dishes to decadent pies. While the tone is humorous and occasionally leans into farce, the mysteries themselves are satisfying, standalone puzzles.

Magdalena Yoder's Personal Journey

While the murder mysteries in each book are solved by the final page, the true thread of continuity lies in Magdalena's relationships. In the early books, readers are introduced to Aaron Miller—whom Magdalena affectionately refers to as her "Pooky Bear." Their relationship undergoes massive shifts: they date, marry early in the series (just prior to the events of Between a Wok and a Hard Place), and eventually divorce. By the time of the later entries, such as Death by Tart Attack, Aaron is Magdalena's ex-husband, returning to cause trouble in Hernia. Following their romance and subsequent interactions is one of the main reasons readers prefer to stick strictly to the publication timeline.

Spin-Offs, Crossovers, and Companion Works

Tamar Myers has written other successful cozy series, most notably the Den of Antiquity series (featuring Charlotte-based antique dealer Abigail Timberlake) and the Belgian Congo series (drawing on Myers' childhood as the daughter of missionaries). Readers often wonder if there are crossover events where Magdalena Yoder meets Abigail Timberlake. While both series share a lighthearted, comedic tone, they are completely separate universes with no crossover stories, cameos, or shared investigations. You can read either series without worrying about missing context from the other.

Can the Books Be Read as Standalones?

Yes, the individual mystery plots in each novel are self-contained. If you pick up a middle-tier book like Custard's Last Stand or Batter Off Dead, you will still enjoy a complete, resolvable whodunit. However, the background relationships, the town's shifting opinions of Magdalena, and her ongoing family drama will make significantly more sense if you start from the beginning with Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth.

Frequently Asked

What is the best starting point for the Pennsylvania Dutch Mysteries?

You should start with the first novel, Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth (1993). This book introduces Magdalena Yoder, her PennDutch Inn, and the core dynamics of Hernia, Pennsylvania.

Do I need to read the books in order?

While the mysteries are standalone, it is highly recommended to read them in publication order. Magdalena's relationships, especially her marriage and eventual divorce with Aaron Miller, develop linearly across the series.

Are there any crossover books with Tamar Myers' Den of Antiquity series?

No. Although both are cozy mystery series written by Tamar Myers, the Pennsylvania Dutch Mysteries and the Den of Antiquity series do not feature any narrative crossovers or shared characters.

Does the series include real recipes?

Yes! True to the culinary themes of the titles, almost every book features authentic, traditional Pennsylvania Dutch recipes included at the end of the text.

How many books are in the Pennsylvania Dutch Mystery series?

There are 24 novels in the series, starting with Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth in 1993 and concluding with Meat Thy Maker in 2023.