Where to Start with Captain Heimrich
For the best experience, readers should start the Captain Heimrich series with the very first novel, Think of Death (1947). While each mystery is a self-contained case, starting at the beginning allows you to watch Merton Heimrich grow from a quiet Lieutenant to a Captain, and follow the development of his personal life. A key milestone occurs in the ninth book, Burnt Offering (1955), which introduces Susan Faye, a fabric shop owner who eventually becomes his wife.
Publication Order vs. Chronological Order
Because the internal chronology of the series aligns with the publication sequence, the publication order is the recommended reading path. However, dedicated fans of the Lockridges' shared universe can also read Heimrich's pre-series appearances. He was introduced as a secondary character in the Mr. and Mrs. North series, beginning with Murder Out of Turn (1941) and appearing again in Death of a Tall Man (1946). Reading these first provides a fun prequel look at the detective before he took center stage.
The Shared Universe and Crossovers
The Lockridges built an interconnected fictional world where characters frequently crossed paths. Captain Heimrich's cases are primarily set in Westchester County and the fictional town of Van Brunt, New York. However, they occasionally overlap with the authors' other series. For instance, NYPD homicide investigator Lieutenant Nathan Shapiro makes a prominent appearance alongside Heimrich in Murder Can't Wait (1964).
The Complete Captain Heimrich Reading List
Here is the complete list of Captain Heimrich novels in recommended reading order, incorporating alternate titles and reconciling variations found in print editions:
- Think of Death (1947)
- I Want to Go Home (1948)
- Spin Your Web, Lady! (1949)
- Foggy, Foggy Death (1950)
- A Client Is Cancelled (1951)
- Death by Association (also published as Trial by Terror) (1952)
- Stand Up and Die (1953)
- Death and the Gentle Bull (also published as Killer in the Straw) (1954)
- Burnt Offering (1955) — Introduces Susan Faye.
- Let Dead Enough Alone (1955/1956)
- Practice to Deceive (also published as Practise to Deceive) (1957)
- Accent on Murder (1958)
- Show Red for Danger (1960)
- With One Stone (also published as No Dignity in Death) (1961)
- First Come, First Kill (1963)
- The Distant Clue (1963)
- Murder Can't Wait (1964) — Crossover featuring Nathan Shapiro.
- Murder Roundabout (1966)
- With Option to Die (1967)
- A Risky Way to Kill (1969/1970)
- Inspector's Holiday (1971)
- Not I, Said the Sparrow (1973/1974)
- Dead Run (1976) — Note: modern digital editions were re-released in 2018.
- The Tenth Life (1977)