How to Read the Expectant Amish Widows Series
If you are looking for sweet, wholesome contemporary Amish romance, Samantha Price’s Expectant Amish Widows series is a perfect destination. The series captures the lives, struggles, and romances of pregnant Amish widows who find hope and new beginnings in tight-knit faith communities. Because each book centers on a different widow with her own unique story, the series is designed with maximum flexibility in mind.
The Best Starting Point for Readers
Although the books are written as standalones, the best way to experience the series is in publication order. Starting with the first book, Amish Widow's Hope, allows you to get familiar with the recurring settings and the gentle community structure that Samantha Price establishes. Reading chronologically by publication also ensures that if a character from a previous book makes a brief background appearance or is mentioned by the community members, you will fully catch the reference.
Expectant Amish Widows Publication Order Checklist
Here is the complete list of the books in the series based on their publication history. While the core series concluded its initial run with book 19 in 2020, author Samantha Price has recently returned to this charming universe with new stories in 2025 and 2026, expanding the total count to 21 books.
- Amish Widow's Hope (2016) – The story of Anita Graber, who returns to Lancaster County expecting a baby and resisting matchmaking, only to find love with Simon.
- The Pregnant Amish Widow (2016) – Follows Grace as she escapes a difficult past, returning to her roots and reconnecting with her first love, Adam.
- Amish Widow's Faith (2016) – Introduces Emily Kauffman, an unconventional matchmaker whose talent sparks community gossip and unexpected romance.
- Their Son's Amish Baby (2016) – A heartwarming tale of family bonds, unexpected pregnancies, and second chances at love.
- Amish Widow's Proposal (2016) – Explores the journey of a pregnant widow navigating community expectations and a surprising proposal.
- A Pregnant Widow's Amish Vacation (2016) – A change of scenery brings new challenges and romantic possibilities for a widow seeking peace.
- The Amish Firefighter's Widow (2016) – A touching story of grief, courage, and finding love again with a dedicated community helper.
- Amish Widow's Secret (2016) – Secrets threaten to disrupt a pregnant widow's chance at a peaceful new life and romance.
- The Middle-Aged Amish Widow (2016) – Focuses on a mature widow finding that second chances at love are not just for the young.
- Amish Widow's Escape (2016) – A widow seeks refuge in a new community to protect her unborn child, finding unexpected support.
- Amish Widow's New Hope (2017) – New beginnings blossom as a young expectant widow learns to trust her heart again.
- Amish Widow's Story (2017) – A deeply personal journey of healing, faith, and the power of love to mend broken hearts.
- Amish Widow's Decision (2017) – Faced with difficult choices about her future, a widow finds guidance through faith and romance.
- Amish Widow's Trust (2018) – Overcoming past hurts is the key to a bright future for a pregnant widow and her new suitor.
- The Amish Potato Farmer's Widow (2018) – A rustic romance set against the hard work of farm life and the sweet promise of new love.
- Amish Widow's Christmas (2018) – Sarah Kurtz faces financial ruin but finds seasonal joy, a new home in Sugarcreek, and a new family.
- Amish Widow's Tears (2018) – A poignant story of navigating deep grief while preparing for the joy of a newborn.
- The Pregnant Amish Nanny (2019) – Courtney takes a job caring for a widower's three children, finding healing for them all.
- Amish Widow's Heart (2020) – Initially written as the series finale, wrapping up the themes of resilience and community.
- Amish Widow's First Love (2025) – A newer addition focusing on a widow who crosses paths with a significant figure from her past.
- Two Amish Widows (2026) – The latest novel, following two pregnant widows with contrasting personalities sharing a roof and finding companionship.
Order Nuances and Platform Numbering Caveats
When searching for these books online, readers should be prepared for some minor numbering differences depending on the platform they use. Specifically, major retailers like Amazon and platforms like Goodreads or Fantastic Fiction often list The Pregnant Amish Nanny as Book 6, shifting subsequent books down by one position. In contrast, some official archives and library databases group it as Book 18 due to its later publication year (2019).
Because the books function entirely as standalones, this discrepancy will not impact your reading enjoyment. You can comfortably read The Pregnant Amish Nanny either early in your journey or save it for later without missing any critical plot points.
What to Know Before You Start
Samantha Price was raised in a Brethren community, which shares historical and cultural roots with the Amish. This background gave her a deep affinity for simple living, community values, and Christian traditions, which shines through in the authenticity of her settings. The series is celebrated for being clean, wholesome, and focused on themes of emotional healing and forgiveness.
If you finish the Expectant Amish Widows and want to read more by Samantha Price, you can dive into her highly popular series The Amish Bonnet Sisters, which features a continuous storyline. It also has a direct next-generation spin-off called Amish Bonnet Sisters: Legacy of Faith. For readers who enjoy interconnected bachelor romances, her Seven Amish Bachelors series is another highly recommended next step.