The Recommended Reading Order
For the best experience, you should read the Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill series in publication order. Because the series features ongoing character development, a central romantic relationship arc between Stormy Morgan and Hunter Ryan, and recurring magical mechanics, starting from the beginning ensures you do not miss key plot points or spoilers. Here is the complete reading order of the main series:
- Sinfully Delicious (2020): Stormy Morgan returns to Shadow Hills, Michigan, after her career as a novelist flops. She expects quiet diner work but instead finds a corpse behind the family business, triggering her magical awakening.
- Caffeinated Calamity (2020): As Stormy tries to get a handle on her newfound witchy powers, she faces another murder case. This book introduces the Winchester witches from Hemlock Cove to the series.
- A Little Slice of Death (2021): Stormy works on mastering her magic while diving into a murder case involving the local pizzeria owner, which stirs up more secrets in Shadow Hills.
- Follow the Crumbs (2021): Magical conspiracies deepen as Stormy uncovers a web of secrets that threatens the stability of her small town.
- Grease the Wheel (2022): Another puzzling mystery forces Stormy to balance her diner duties, her growing magical abilities, and a complicated local investigation.
- We All Scream (2022): Summer brings ice cream, heat, and a chilly murder case that Stormy must solve before the killer strikes again.
- The Secret's in the Sauce (2023): Culinary secrets and magical spells mix in this installment as Stormy investigates a local death with deep roots in the community.
- As the Cookie Crumbles (2023): Stormy faces a sweet but deadly mystery where local gossip and magical clues are the only way to find the culprit.
- Chilled to the Bone (2024): A winter mystery that challenges Stormy's magical skills and tests the limits of her investigative abilities.
- Sinister Snack Attack (2024): Stormy deals with a quick-paced mystery that threatens the peaceful routine of the Two Broomsticks diner.
- Once Bitten, Twice Dead (2025): Stormy finds two teenagers who disappeared ten years prior standing in the road—without having aged a single day.
- Wham, Bam, In a Jam (2025): A day of morel hunting with Hunter Ryan turns dark when they discover the body of an isolated local woman, leading to a complex web of secrets.
- Breaking the Mold (2026): Stormy deals with the domestic challenge of her grandfather moving in while investigating the murder of a woman with a colorful past.
- Drunk & Disorderly (Scheduled for December 2026): The fourteenth entry in the series, continuing the magical adventures of Stormy, Hunter, and the Winchester family.
Crossover Connections: Wicked Witches of the Midwest
One of the highlights for fans of Amanda M. Lee's books is the shared magical universe. Starting in Caffeinated Calamity, characters from the author's popular Wicked Witches of the Midwest series (set in Hemlock Cove) begin crossing over into Shadow Hills. The Winchester witches become recurring mentors and friends, assisting Stormy as she learns to control her powers. While you do not need to read the entire Winchester series to enjoy Stormy's adventures, doing so provides fun context for their eccentric personalities.
Publication Order vs. Chronological Order
Fortunately, the chronological order of the Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill series matches the publication order. There are no confusing prequels or flashbacks that disrupt the timeline. However, if you are attempting to read Amanda M. Lee's entire shared universe chronologically, you will want to interspace the Two Broomsticks books with the Winchester Witches books and other side series using the author's official master timeline.
Practical Reader Advice
If you are new to the series, the absolute best starting point is Sinfully Delicious. Reading the books as standalones is not recommended because the romantic progression between Stormy and Hunter, the development of Stormy's magic, and the overarching town lore build directly from one book to the next. The tone is light, humorous, and full of snappy dialogue, making it a perfect quick escape for fans of paranormal cozy mysteries.
What to Know Before You Start
Set in the fictional town of Shadow Hills, Michigan, the series blends traditional cozy mystery tropes (quirky relatives, nosy neighbors, a handsome high school sweetheart, and a family diner) with supernatural elements. Stormy is a relatable, slightly cynical protagonist whose transition from a failed author to a practicing witch offers a satisfying journey of self-discovery and resilience.