Katie May Books in Order

Picture a young college student, juggling law school dreams and a daring bet with her sister, who suddenly becomes a USA Today bestselling author—meet Katie May! This vibrant storyteller has taken ...

Book links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we earn a commission.

Publication Order of Reject Island Books

Publication Order of Dressed to Kill Books

Publication Order of Society of Shifters Books

Picture a young college student, juggling law school dreams and a daring bet with her sister, who suddenly becomes a USA Today bestselling author—meet Katie May! This vibrant storyteller has taken the literary world by storm with her sassy heroines, unconventional romances, and a wicked sense of humor that hooks readers from page one.

Katie May, a caffeine-fueled, horror-movie-obsessed writer, burst onto the scene with her debut paranormal romance at just twenty years old. Known for her reverse harem novels that blend paranormal, horror, fantasy, and comedy, May has penned over three dozen works, captivating fans with her emotionally vulnerable heroines and possessive, slightly unhinged alpha males.

The Making of Katie May

Born with a passion for storytelling, Katie May started scribbling short stories in elementary school, sharing them with her teachers. By college, she was studying political science and legal studies, aiming for a law career—until a fateful bet with her sister changed everything. Tasked with publishing her first book, May dove in headfirst, writing on her phone in the Notes app and uploading her debut, The Darkness We Crave, to Amazon with a cheap cover and zero expectations. To her shock, it exploded in popularity, launching her into the spotlight as a bestselling author.

Inspired by L.J. Smith’s Night World series, which she devoured in middle school, May developed a love for witches, vampires, and soulmate-driven narratives. Her horror movie fandom also shapes her work, infusing it with dark, thrilling vibes and unexpected twists that keep readers guessing.

Katie May’s Unforgettable Stories

Katie May’s bibliography is a dazzling mix of genres, but her reverse harem romances—where strong heroines win the hearts of multiple devoted men—steal the show. Her debut, The Darkness We Crave (2018), kicks off the Together We Fall series, following a fierce heroine navigating a post-apocalyptic world with a group of loyal, dangerous men. Fans love its blend of humor, heart, and high stakes.

In Monsters (Prodigium Academy #1), May crafts a darkly humorous tale of a badass heroine entangled with supernatural suitors at a gothic academy, packed with twists and psychotic charm. Charming Devils explores a gothic romance with a rebellious heroine facing off against devilish antiheroes, while Gangs and Ghosts (Beyond the Shadows #1) mixes paranormal mystery with May’s signature wit, inspired by her love for horror films. Each story showcases her knack for blending emotional depth, steamy romance, and unpredictable plots.

May’s writing style is bold and playful, with heroines who are unapologetically fierce and male leads who range from swoon-worthy to deliciously unhinged. Her ability to weave humor into dark, fantastical settings makes her books addictive, earning her a loyal fanbase across paranormal, fantasy, and horror genres.

Why Katie May Matters

Katie May’s impact lies in her fearless approach to storytelling, breaking boundaries with unconventional romances and strong, relatable heroines. Her reverse harem novels have carved a niche in the romance genre, offering readers escapist adventures with emotional resonance. By tackling themes like empowerment, survival, and love in chaotic worlds, she connects with fans who crave bold, diverse narratives.

Her journey from a college student to an international bestseller also inspires aspiring authors, proving that passion and perseverance can turn a bet into a career. With over 100,000 Goodreads ratings averaging 4.18, May’s influence continues to grow, resonating with readers who love their romance with a side of danger and humor.

  • Fun Fact: Katie writes all her novels on her phone in the Notes app, a habit her author friends jokingly call ‘heathenish’!
  • Key Works: The Darkness We Crave, Monsters, Charming Devils, Gangs and Ghosts
  • Awards: USA Today and International Bestselling Author

Ready to dive into a world of sassy heroines and thrilling romance? Snag Monsters or The Darkness We Crave and get lost in Katie May’s addictive blend of paranormal and humor!

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Katie May?

Katie May is a USA Today bestselling author known for her reverse harem romances blending paranormal, horror, and humor. Starting her career at twenty with a bet, she’s written over three dozen novels featuring sassy heroines and devoted, slightly unhinged male leads.

What inspired Katie May to start writing?

Katie May’s writing was sparked by a bet with her sister, leading to her debut novel. Her love for L.J. Smith’s Night World series and horror movies fueled her passion for paranormal romance and thrilling, twist-filled stories.

What are Katie May’s best books?

Katie May’s top books include The Darkness We Crave, a post-apocalyptic romance; Monsters, a gothic academy tale; Charming Devils, a dark romance; and Gangs and Ghosts, a witty paranormal mystery, all showcasing her signature humor.

What is Katie May’s writing style like?

Katie May’s style is bold, playful, and addictive, blending steamy reverse harem romance with humor, horror, and fantasy. Her fierce heroines and possessive, unhinged heroes shine in dark, twisty plots that keep readers hooked.

How did Katie May become a bestselling author?

Katie May became a bestseller after publishing The Darkness We Crave on a bet at age twenty. With no editor or experience, her debut gained traction when a famous indie author promoted it, launching her career.