Lyndsay Faye Books in Order

Picture a storyteller who swapped stage lights for the gritty streets of 19th-century New York—meet Lyndsay Faye! This American author, once a corset-clad actress, now weaves historical crime ficti...

Book links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we earn a commission.

Publication Order of Bibliomysteries Books

Chronological Order of Bibliomysteries Books

Publication Order of Anthologies

OrdBook
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon

Picture a storyteller who swapped stage lights for the gritty streets of 19th-century New York—meet Lyndsay Faye! This American author, once a corset-clad actress, now weaves historical crime fiction that pulses with vivid characters and meticulous research. Her Timothy Wilde series, starting with The Gods of Gotham, has captivated readers with its thrilling blend of mystery and social justice, earning her a spot as a leading voice in the genre.

Faye’s knack for bringing the past to life with flair and authenticity makes her stories irresistible. Whether it’s the chaos of early NYPD days or a feminist reimagining of classic literature, her prose crackles with energy. Let’s dive into the world of Lyndsay Faye, where history meets heart-pounding drama!

The Making of Lyndsay Faye

Born in Northern California and raised in the Pacific Northwest, Lyndsay Faye grew up with a love for stories. A dual degree in English and Performance from Notre Dame de Namur University set the stage for her early career as a professional actress in the Bay Area, often performing in period roles that sparked her fascination with history. In 2005, she moved to Manhattan to chase acting dreams, but when her day-job restaurant was demolished, she turned to writing. Her lifelong passion for Sherlock Holmes, ignited at age 10 by her father’s suggestion to read The Adventure of the Speckled Band, shaped her path as a mystery writer.

Lyndsay Faye’s Unforgettable Stories

Faye’s debut novel, Dust and Shadow (2009), pits Sherlock Holmes against Jack the Ripper in a gripping Victorian thriller. Praised for its rigorous research and vivid depiction of London, it marked Faye as a master of historical crime fiction. Her Timothy Wilde series—The Gods of Gotham (2012), Seven for a Secret (2013), and The Fatal Flame (2015)—follows a reluctant policeman navigating corruption and crime in 1840s New York. The series, nominated for an Edgar Award, blends heart-stopping action with themes of abolition and justice, reflecting Faye’s deep research into the NYPD’s origins.

In Jane Steele (2016), Faye reimagines Jane Eyre’s heroine as a gutsy serial killer, earning critical acclaim for its dark humor and feminist edge. The Paragon Hotel (2019) tackles racism and the Ku Klux Klan in 1921 Portland, showcasing Faye’s ability to weave social commentary into suspenseful narratives. Her lush, queer take on Hamlet, The King of Infinite Space (2021), proves her versatility, setting Shakespearean drama in modern-day New York. Faye’s style—rich, character-driven, and historically precise—makes every page a journey.

Why Lyndsay Faye Matters

Lyndsay Faye’s work does more than entertain; it illuminates erased voices from history, from enslaved Northerners to marginalized women. Her meticulous research and vibrant storytelling have earned her international acclaim, with translations in 15 languages and praise from authors like Gillian Flynn. As a mentor with Mystery Writers of America and Girls Write Now, Faye nurtures new talent, ensuring her influence extends beyond the page. Her ability to blend thrilling plots with social insight cements her as a vital voice in historical fiction.

  • About Lyndsay Faye
  • Born: Northern California, USA
  • Key Works: The Gods of Gotham, Jane Steele, The Paragon Hotel
  • Awards: Edgar Award nominee, American Library Association’s Best Mystery (2012)
  • Fun Fact: A proud member of the Baker Street Irregulars, a Sherlock Holmes society

Ready to step into Faye’s thrilling world? Snag The Gods of Gotham and dive into her masterful blend of history and mystery!

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Lyndsay Faye?

Lyndsay Faye is an American author and former actress known for her historical crime fiction. Her Timothy Wilde series, starting with The Gods of Gotham, blends vivid 19th-century New York settings with gripping mysteries. A Sherlock Holmes enthusiast, she’s also written acclaimed novels like Jane Steele.

What are Lyndsay Faye’s best books?

Lyndsay Faye’s top books include The Gods of Gotham, an Edgar-nominated mystery set in 1840s New York, Jane Steele, a feminist twist on Jane Eyre, and The Paragon Hotel, a thrilling tale of 1921 Portland. Her Sherlockian Dust and Shadow is also a fan favorite.

What inspired Lyndsay Faye to write historical fiction?

Lyndsay Faye’s love for history, sparked by her acting in period roles and fascination with Sherlock Holmes, inspired her historical fiction. Her research into the NYPD’s 1845 origins and the Irish Potato Famine fueled her Timothy Wilde series, blending gritty history with compelling narratives.

Why is Lyndsay Faye’s Timothy Wilde series so popular?

Lyndsay Faye’s Timothy Wilde series, starting with The Gods of Gotham, is popular for its vivid 1840s New York setting, complex characters, and gripping crime plots. Faye’s meticulous research and themes of social justice, like abolition, resonate with readers, earning critical acclaim.

How does Lyndsay Faye incorporate social issues into her books?

Lyndsay Faye weaves social issues like racism, corruption, and gender inequality into her novels. The Gods of Gotham tackles slavery, The Paragon Hotel confronts the Ku Klux Klan, and Jane Steele explores feminist themes, blending thrilling plots with insightful commentary.