Olivia Matthews Books in Order

  • 29 Books
  • 2017 – 2024 Published

Amazon links here are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reading order
01
Cozy Case Files Volume 1
2017 By: Cynthia Riggs, Mindy Quigley
02
Cozy Case Files Volume 2
Cozy Case Files Volume 2
2017 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Hannah Dennison, Cate Conte, Diane Kelly, E.J. Copperman, Ellie Alexander, Cynthia Riggs, Susan C. Shea, Mindy Quigley
03
Cozy Case Files Volume 3
Cozy Case Files Volume 3
2017 By: M.C. Beaton, Donna Andrews, Ellie Alexander, Mindy Quigley
04
Cozy Case Files Volume 4
Cozy Case Files Volume 4
2018 By: Parnell Hall, Shari Randall, Ellen Hart, Ellie Alexander, Frances Brody, Tessa Arlen, Vivien Chien, Julia Chapman, Paige Shelton, Jane K. Cleland, Mindy Quigley
05
Cozy Case Files Volume 5
Cozy Case Files Volume 5
2018 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Carola Dunn, Sheila Connolly, Ellie Alexander, Susan C. Shea, Judith Flanders, Mindy Quigley, Auralee Wallace
06
Cozy Case Files Volume 6
Cozy Case Files Volume 6
2019 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Cate Conte, Kylie Logan, Leonard Goldberg, Allison Montclair, Ellen Hart, Sheila Connolly, Mindy Quigley
07
Cozy Case Files Volume 7
2019 By: Donna Andrews, Diane Kelly, Ellen Crosby, Ellie Alexander, Vivien Chien, Ashley Weaver, Mindy Quigley
08
Cozy Case Files Volume 8
Cozy Case Files Volume 8
2020 By: M.C. Beaton, Diane Kelly, Vivien Chien, Paige Shelton, SusanCox, Elizabeth Penney, Mindy Quigley
09
Cozy Case Files Volume 9
Cozy Case Files Volume 9
2020 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Hannah Dennison, Kylie Logan, Leonard Goldberg, Susanna Calkins, Allison Montclair, Ellie Alexander, Eve Calder, Mindy Quigley
10
Cozy Case Files Volume 10
Cozy Case Files Volume 10
2020 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Cate Conte, Diane Kelly, Ellen Hart, Ellie Alexander, Vivien Chien, Jane K. Cleland, Ashley Weaver, SusanCox, Elizabeth Penney, Mindy Quigley
11
Cozy Case Files Volume 11
Cozy Case Files Volume 11
2021 By: Diane Kelly, Ellie Alexander, Vivien Chien, Paige Shelton, Mariah Fredericks, Elizabeth Penney, Mindy Quigley
12
Cozy Case Files Volume 12
Cozy Case Files Volume 12
2021 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Hannah Dennison, Cate Conte, Kylie Logan, Leonard Goldberg, Allison Montclair, Sheila Connolly, Ellie Alexander, Ashley Weaver, S.C. Perkins, Eve Calder, Jess Dylan, Mindy Quigley, Meri Allen
13
Cozy Case Files Volume 13
Cozy Case Files Volume 13
2021 By: Mindy Quigley
14
Cozy Case Files Volume 14
Cozy Case Files Volume 14
2022 By: Diane Kelly, Gigi Pandian, Ellie Alexander, Paige Shelton, Mindy Quigley, Korina Moss
15
Cozy Case Files Volume 15
Cozy Case Files Volume 15
2022 By: Mindy Quigley
16
Cozy Case Files Volume 16
Cozy Case Files Volume 16
2022 By: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Diane Kelly, Elizabeth Penney, Mindy Quigley, Korina Moss, M. C. Beaton
17
Cozy Case Files Volume 17
Cozy Case Files Volume 17
2023 With: Rhys Bowen, Diane Kelly, Gigi Pandian, Ellie Alexander, Paige Shelton, Jean-Luc Bannalec, Olivia Blacke, Mindy Quigley, Clare Broyles, Korina Moss, Anastasia Hastings
18
Cozy Case Files, Volume 18
Cozy Case Files, Volume 18
2023 With: Carolyn Haines, Donna Andrews, Leonard Goldberg, Allison Montclair, Vivien Chien, Olivia Blacke, Mindy Quigley, Meri Allen, Katharine Schellman, Korina Moss
19
Cozy Case Files, Volume 19
Cozy Case Files, Volume 19
2023 By: M.C. Beaton, Donna Andrews, Cate Conte, Diane Kelly, Ellie Alexander, Cynthia Riggs, R.W. Green, Elizabeth Penney, Korina Moss, Celeste Connally
20
Cozy Case Files, Volume 20
Cozy Case Files, Volume 20
2024 With: Rhys Bowen, Gigi Pandian, Ellie Alexander, Paige Shelton, Jennifer J. Chow, Olivia Blacke, Mindy Quigley, Clare Broyles, Anastasia Hastings
5 of 5 reading orders shown

Picture a storyteller who spins cozy mysteries with heart and humor, inviting readers to uncover heroes in the most unexpected places—meet Olivia Matthews! As the pseudonym of Patricia Sargeant, a national bestselling author, Matthews crafts tales that blend warmth, wit, and whodunits, captivating cozy mystery fans with her vibrant characters and immersive settings. From her roots in New York City to her home in Ohio, Matthews’s stories reflect her love for ordinary people rising to extraordinary challenges.

The Making of Olivia Matthews

Born and raised in the bustling streets of New York City, Patricia Sargeant, who writes as Olivia Matthews, discovered her passion for storytelling at age nine. A voracious reader, she was inspired by authors like Walter Mosley and Tami Hoag, who placed everyday characters in thrilling situations. After a career in journalism and publishing, Sargeant turned to fiction, adopting the Matthews pen name to explore the cozy mystery genre, where her knack for crafting relatable heroes shines.

Olivia Matthews’s Unforgettable Stories

Matthews’s cozy mysteries are a delightful mix of charm, intrigue, and community. Her Sister Lou Mystery series, starting with Mayhem & Mass (2017), follows Sister Louise “Lou” LaSalle, a Catholic sister turned amateur sleuth in Briar Coast, New York. Lou’s determination to solve murders, like that of her friend in the debut novel, showcases Matthews’s skill in blending faith and grit. The Spice Isle Bakery Mysteries, beginning with Against the Currant (2023), transports readers to Brooklyn’s Little Caribbean, where Lyndsay Murray’s bakery becomes a hub for solving crimes with a Grenadian flair. The Peach Coast Library Mysteries, like Murder by Page One (2021), feature librarian Marvey Harris navigating small-town Georgia’s secrets. Matthews’s style—rich with cultural details and heartfelt characters—makes each series a cozy escape.

Her stories stand out for their diverse casts and settings, reflecting Sargeant’s Grenadian heritage and commitment to authentic representation. Whether it’s Sister Lou’s faith-driven resolve or Lyndsay’s family ties, Matthews’s protagonists embody resilience, making her books resonate with readers seeking both mystery and meaning.

Why Olivia Matthews Matters

Olivia Matthews has carved a unique niche in cozy mysteries, bringing underrepresented voices and cultures to the forefront. Her series celebrate Caribbean heritage and strong female leads, inspiring readers to embrace their inner heroes. Beyond her books, Sargeant’s workshops and online courses through The Write Spot empower aspiring authors, cementing her legacy as both a storyteller and mentor. Her work has earned praise from outlets like Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews, proving her impact on the genre.

  • Pen Name: Olivia Matthews (Patricia Sargeant)
  • Key Works: Mayhem & Mass, Against the Currant, Murder by Page One
  • Awards: National bestselling and award-winning author
  • Hometown: New York City, now resides in Ohio

Ready to cozy up with a mystery that’s equal parts heart and suspense? Grab Against the Currant and dive into Olivia Matthews’s vibrant world of sleuthing and spice!

Frequently Asked

Who is Olivia Matthews?

Olivia Matthews is the cozy mystery pseudonym of Patricia Sargeant, a bestselling author from New York City now living in Ohio. Known for series like Sister Lou Mysteries and Spice Isle Bakery Mysteries, she crafts heartwarming whodunits with diverse, relatable heroes.

What are Olivia Matthews’s best books?

Olivia Matthews shines in Mayhem & Mass (Sister Lou Mysteries), Against the Currant (Spice Isle Bakery Mysteries), and Murder by Page One (Peach Coast Library Mysteries). Each blends cozy charm with gripping mysteries and vibrant characters.

What inspired Olivia Matthews to write cozy mysteries?

Patricia Sargeant, as Olivia Matthews, was inspired by authors like Walter Mosley and her work with Catholic sisters. She wanted to create cozy mysteries featuring ordinary people, like Sister Lou, finding heroism in extraordinary situations.

What is the Spice Isle Bakery Mysteries series about?

The Spice Isle Bakery Mysteries, starting with Against the Currant, follows Lyndsay Murray, a Grenadian-American baker in Brooklyn’s Little Caribbean. She solves murders, like a rival’s death, while celebrating her heritage through family and food.

How does Olivia Matthews contribute to the literary community?

As Patricia Sargeant, Olivia Matthews mentors aspiring writers through workshops and online courses at The Write Spot. Her diverse, inclusive cozy mysteries also amplify underrepresented voices, enriching the genre.