Picture an American storyteller who whisked readers to the shadowy alleys of 18th-century London with a tale of poison and empowerment—meet Sarah Penner! Her debut novel, The Lost Apothecary, became an instant New York Times bestseller, captivating readers with its blend of historical fiction, mystery, and fierce female characters. Penner, a former finance professional turned full-time author, crafts stories that resonate across centuries, exploring women’s resilience and rebellion.
With her vivid prose and meticulous research, Penner has carved a unique niche in historical fiction. Her tales weave together atmospheric settings, intricate plots, and themes of female empowerment, making her a beloved voice for readers who crave both suspense and substance. Let’s dive into her journey, from corporate spreadsheets to spellbinding stories!
The Making of Sarah Penner
Born and raised in Kansas, Sarah Penner grew up in a log cabin nestled in the woods, a setting that likely sparked her love for evocative storytelling. A graduate of the University of Kansas, she spent thirteen years navigating the structured world of corporate finance. Yet, her creative side simmered beneath the surface, fueled by a passion for history and writing. Penner’s leap into authorship wasn’t overnight—she honed her craft in her spare time, eventually joining the Historical Novel Society and the Women’s Fiction Writers Association to connect with fellow storytellers.
Her inspiration for The Lost Apothecary struck in 2016 while browsing a book on mudlarking, the practice of scavenging treasures along the River Thames. A fragment of a 17th-century apothecary jar ignited her imagination, leading her to envision a hidden shop dispensing poisons to women seeking liberation. Despite over a hundred rejections for an earlier manuscript, Penner’s persistence paid off, and her debut novel launched her into literary stardom.
Sarah Penner’s Unforgettable Stories
Penner’s debut, The Lost Apothecary (2021), is a gripping tale set in 18th-century London, where Nella, a secretive apothecary, crafts poisons to free women from abusive men. The story alternates with present-day London, where historian Caroline uncovers Nella’s legacy, blending mystery, betrayal, and female solidarity. With over a million copies sold and translations in forty languages, the novel’s gothic atmosphere and feminist themes have captivated readers worldwide.
Her second novel, The London Séance Society (2023), delves into spiritualism and deception, following a young woman navigating the supernatural underworld of Victorian London. Penner’s upcoming release, The Amalfi Curse (April 2025), promises sunken treasure, forbidden love, and ancient magic on Italy’s sun-drenched coast. Each work showcases Penner’s signature style: richly detailed historical settings, rebellious female protagonists, and plots that keep readers guessing until the final page.
Penner’s writing blends historical accuracy with a touch of magical realism, creating worlds that feel both authentic and enchanting. Her research—poring over manuscripts in the British Library or studying 18th-century poisoning cases—grounds her stories in vivid detail, while her focus on women’s agency resonates with modern audiences. Whether it’s a poison-laced vial or a séance gone awry, Penner’s tales are as intoxicating as the potions she describes.
Why Sarah Penner Matters
Sarah Penner’s work transcends entertainment, offering a lens into the often-overlooked lives of women in history. By spotlighting their struggles and triumphs, she reclaims their stories, reminding readers of the power of resilience and ingenuity. Her novels have struck a chord with book clubs and readers seeking narratives that blend suspense with social commentary, earning praise from authors like Kate Quinn and Fiona Davis.
Penner’s impact extends beyond the page. As a member of her local animal shelter’s Board of Directors, she champions community causes, reflecting the compassion that infuses her characters. Her journey from finance to fiction inspires aspiring writers, proving that passion and perseverance can rewrite one’s destiny. With a drama series adaptation of The Lost Apothecary in development at Fox, Penner’s influence is only growing.
- Birthplace: Kansas, USA
- Key Works: The Lost Apothecary (2021), The London Séance Society (2023), The Amalfi Curse (2025)
- Notable Achievement: New York Times bestseller with over a million copies sold
Ready to step into a world of secrets and rebellion? Snag The Lost Apothecary and dive into Sarah Penner’s intoxicating historical fiction!