Sarah Stewart Taylor Books in Order

Picture a Vermont farm where sheep graze, blueberries ripen, and a mystery unfolds on the page—meet Sarah Stewart Taylor! This American author weaves gripping tales that dance between Irish landsca...

Book links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we earn a commission.

Picture a Vermont farm where sheep graze, blueberries ripen, and a mystery unfolds on the page—meet Sarah Stewart Taylor! This American author weaves gripping tales that dance between Irish landscapes and historical enigmas, captivating readers with her Maggie D'arcy and Sweeney St. George series. With a knack for blending past and present, Taylor’s stories are as lush as the Dublin hills she loves.

From her early days studying Irish literature to her acclaimed novels, Taylor’s journey is a testament to her passion for storytelling. Let’s dive into the life and works of this mystery maven who’s redefining the genre with her atmospheric prose and intricate plots.

The Making of Sarah Stewart Taylor

Born and raised on Long Island, New York, Sarah Stewart Taylor’s love for storytelling took root early. She studied at Middlebury College in Vermont before crossing the Atlantic to Trinity College in Dublin, where she earned a master’s in Irish Literature. Dublin’s vibrant 1990s energy—alive with cultural and economic shifts—captivated her, sparking a lifelong love for Irish culture. Before becoming a full-time author, Taylor worked as a journalist and teacher, honing her ability to craft compelling narratives. Her time in Ireland, coupled with her New England roots, shaped her unique voice, which blends historical depth with modern suspense.

Sarah Stewart Taylor’s Unforgettable Stories

Taylor’s debut, O’ Artful Death (2003), introduced Sweeney St. George, an art history professor with a passion for gravestone iconography. This Agatha Award-nominated novel follows Sweeney as she unravels a century-old murder in Vermont’s Byzantium Art Colony, blending cozy mystery with rich historical detail. The series, spanning four books, showcases Taylor’s knack for weaving art, history, and suspense into intricate plots.

In 2020, Taylor launched the Maggie D’arcy series with The Mountains Wild, a gripping tale of a Long Island detective drawn to Ireland to solve her cousin’s disappearance. Praised for its lyrical prose and vivid Irish settings, the novel landed on multiple Best of 2020 lists. Follow-ups like A Distant Grave, The Drowning Sea, and A Stolen Child deepen Maggie’s journey, exploring themes of family, loss, and resilience. Taylor’s ability to craft psychologically rich characters and atmospheric settings has earned comparisons to Tana French, with critics lauding her “razor-sharp” storytelling.

Her latest venture, Agony Hill (2024), kicks off a historical mystery series set in 1960s Vermont, proving Taylor’s versatility. Whether it’s Dublin’s bustling streets or Vermont’s quiet farms, her settings are characters in their own right, rendered with a painter’s eye for detail.

Why Sarah Stewart Taylor Matters

Sarah Stewart Taylor has carved a niche in mystery literature by blending historical and cultural elements with modern crime narratives. Her Maggie D’arcy series, in particular, resonates with readers for its authentic portrayal of Irish culture and its exploration of personal and societal transitions. Nominated for prestigious awards like the Dashiell Hammett Prize, Taylor’s work elevates the genre with its emotional depth and meticulous research. Her stories invite readers to explore not just whodunits but the human connections that drive them, making her a standout voice in contemporary fiction.

By celebrating both her Irish and New England heritage, Taylor bridges worlds, offering readers a window into the complexities of identity and place. Her growing fanbase eagerly awaits each new release, a testament to her lasting impact.

  • Birthplace: Long Island, New York
  • Key Works: O’ Artful Death, The Mountains Wild, A Stolen Child, Agony Hill
  • Awards: Nominated for Agatha Award, Dashiell Hammett Prize, MWA Sue Grafton Memorial Award
  • Fun Fact: She raises sheep and grows blueberries on her Vermont farm!

Ready to lose yourself in a mystery that spans continents and centuries? Snag The Mountains Wild and dive into Sarah Stewart Taylor’s thrilling world of secrets and suspense!

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Sarah Stewart Taylor?

Sarah Stewart Taylor is an American mystery author known for her Maggie D’arcy and Sweeney St. George series. Blending Irish culture and historical intrigue, she crafts atmospheric novels from her Vermont farm, where she raises sheep and grows blueberries.

What are Sarah Stewart Taylor’s best books?

Sarah Stewart Taylor’s top books include The Mountains Wild, a gripping Irish-set mystery, O’ Artful Death, an Agatha-nominated cozy, and A Stolen Child, a thrilling Maggie D’arcy tale. Her latest, Agony Hill, kicks off a 1960s Vermont series.

What inspired Sarah Stewart Taylor’s writing?

Sarah Stewart Taylor’s writing draws from her time studying Irish literature in Dublin and her New England roots. The vibrant 1990s Dublin scene and her love for history and art fuel her intricate mysteries.

Why is Sarah Stewart Taylor compared to Tana French?

Sarah Stewart Taylor earns Tana French comparisons for her lyrical prose, vivid Irish settings, and psychologically rich characters. Her Maggie D’arcy series, like French’s work, blends atmospheric crime with deep emotional resonance.

What themes does Sarah Stewart Taylor explore?

Sarah Stewart Taylor’s novels explore family, loss, identity, and cultural transitions. Her Maggie D’arcy series delves into Irish-American connections, while her Sweeney St. George books weave art and history into suspenseful mysteries.