Books On Board
author Reading Order

Andrea Carter Books in Order

6 Books
2015 – 2023 Published
Jump to reading order
Affiliate links: We may earn a commission on purchases made at no extra cost to you.
Reading order

The Recommended Reading Order for Andrea Carter's Books

For the best reading experience, it is highly recommended to read the Inishowen Mysteries in their publication order. Because the books follow the ongoing personal life, emotional healing, and evolving relationships of solicitor Benedicta 'Ben' O’Keeffe, reading them in order allows you to fully appreciate the character development and the slow-burning subplots that span the entire series.

Here is the complete list of Andrea Carter's novels in their recommended reading order:

  1. Death at Whitewater Church (2015) – The debut novel introduces Ben O'Keeffe, who discovers a skeleton inside a bricked-up crypt in a deconsecrated Donegal church. The investigation forces the tight-knit local community to confront secrets dating back to a tragic wedding day three decades earlier.
  2. Treacherous Strand (2016) – When the body of a French woman washes up on a remote Donegal beach, the death is initially ruled a suicide. However, Ben’s search for the truth leads her to local suspicions and a chilling connection to a past doomsday cult.
  3. The Well of Ice (2017) – Set during a freezing winter in Glendara, this installment finds Ben dealing with a pub fire, a missing barmaid, and a hostile town that seems determined to keep its secrets buried in the snow.
  4. Murder at Greysbridge (2018) – A classic country-house mystery style story set during a wedding. When a guest is found dead and another soon follows, Ben is trapped on an island off the coast of Donegal, forced to untangle a web of family grudges.
  5. The Body Falls (2019 / 2020) – A group of tourists is stranded in Glendara by a heavy storm, and tension turns to terror when a body is discovered. Ben must navigate suspicion and rising panic within a confined group.
  6. Death Writes (2023) – The sixth novel centers around a literary festival where a famous local author is poisoned on stage. Ben is pulled into a dark investigation involving literary rivalries, hidden manuscripts, and long-held grudges.

Chronological vs. Publication Order

There are no complex timeline shifts or prequels in the Inishowen Mysteries. The chronological order of the stories matches their publication order exactly. Each novel picks up some months after the events of the previous book, reflecting the changing seasons and the natural progression of Ben's life in the small town of Glendara on the Inishowen Peninsula. Reading out of order will expose major spoilers regarding Ben's personal life, past trauma, and her relationships with local police and residents.

What to Know Before You Start

Before diving into Andrea Carter's work, it helps to understand the unique blend of styles she brings to the crime fiction genre:

  • A Legal Insider's Eye: Carter studied law at Trinity College Dublin and ran the country's northernmost solicitor's practice on the Inishowen Peninsula for ten years. This firsthand legal experience brings realistic procedural details, administrative realities, and courtroom depth to Ben O'Keeffe's work.
  • Cozy Meets Gritty: The series has been widely praised as a modern-day nod to classic Agatha Christie-style whodunits, but it also features contemporary, dark themes such as cults, domestic secrets, and psychological struggles. Critics frequently compare the atmospheric, small-town tension to TV dramas like Broadchurch or Grantchester.
  • The Donegal Setting: The rugged, windswept Inishowen Peninsula in County Donegal is practically a character itself. Carter’s writing highlights the contrast between the stunning natural beauty of the Irish coast and the claustrophobic nature of a community where everyone knows your business—and your secrets.

Short Stories and Spin-offs

While the six core novels make up the bulk of Andrea Carter's bibliography, she has also written acclaimed short fiction. Her short story titled 'The Lamb' was published in the 2019 legal-themed anthology Counterparts: A Synergy of Law and Literature (published by The Stinging Fly Press and edited by Danielle McLaughlin). The story garnered significant critical acclaim and was nominated for the Writing.ie Short Story of the Year at the 2019 An Post Irish Book Awards. Although it is not a direct mystery case for Ben O'Keeffe, it shares Carter's signature focus on moral dilemmas, legal themes, and human complexity.

Television Adaptation

For readers who enjoy seeing their favorite books on screen, a television adaptation titled Donegal—The Inishowen Mysteries is in development. The project is structured as a co-production between Zanzibar Films in Ireland and Neshama Entertainment in Canada, with plans to film on location in Donegal to capture the authentic, rugged atmosphere of the books.

Frequently Asked

QWhat is the best book to start with for Andrea Carter?

The best starting point is Death at Whitewater Church (2015). This debut novel introduces the main characters, the setting of Glendara, and the foundational subplots of Ben O'Keeffe's personal history.

QDo you need to read the Inishowen Mysteries in order?

Yes, it is highly recommended. While the individual murder mysteries in each book are resolved by the end of the novel, the character growth, personal trauma, and romantic subplots develop continuously across the series.

QWhere is the Inishowen Mystery series set?

The series is set on the remote and rugged Inishowen Peninsula in County Donegal, Ireland, primarily in the fictional small town of Glendara.

QWas Andrea Carter really a solicitor?

Yes. Andrea Carter studied law at Trinity College Dublin and ran a solicitor's practice in Inishowen for ten years before returning to Dublin to work as a barrister, which informs the legal accuracy of her novels.

QAre there any spin-offs or short stories associated with the series?

Carter has written short stories, most notably 'The Lamb', which was featured in the 2019 anthology Counterparts and nominated for an Irish Book Award, though it is a standalone story rather than a direct series tie-in.